Inspector Proposes Reclaiming VND 72 Billion from Scenia Bay Project, Where 704 Apartments Lack Land Titles

Government inspectors have recommended the recovery of 72 billion VND from the Scenia Bay project due to improper land use fee deductions. They have also urged the Khanh Hoa Provincial People's Committee to review the land allocation and pricing procedures. Despite having delivered 704 apartments, the project has yet to issue pink books to residents.

0
14

Scenia Bay, developed by Nha Trang Bay Joint Stock Company, is a mixed-use complex featuring a hotel, commercial services, and residential apartments located at 25-26 Pham Van Dong Street, Bac Nha Trang Ward, Khanh Hoa Province.

The project was approved and commenced in 2017, with a total investment of over 2 trillion VND. According to the approved schedule, construction was expected to be completed by the end of 2019. In reality, the main components were substantially finished within this timeframe. The developer has handed over 704 apartments to customers, with many residents already settled in.

However, the legal aspects of the project have lagged behind construction progress. As of the inspection conclusion in October 2025, the 704 apartments had not yet received their land-use certificates.

Front view of Scenia Bay – Photo: Scenia Bay

According to the Government Inspectorate’s conclusion announced on December 29, 2025, the land for the project was originally under the management of the Ministry of National Defense. The local authorities reclaimed the land and allocated it to the company without a public auction, which violates regulations on public land management. When determining financial obligations, Khanh Hoa Province approved a land price lower than the applicable rate in 2014, altering the land-use fee payable.

During the land-use fee calculation, the province allowed the developer to deduct 72 billion VND for compensation and support (including 55 billion VND related to the Ministry of National Defense and 17 billion VND for two other companies). The Government Inspectorate determined this deduction was improper and recommended its full recovery for the state budget.

The project underwent adjustments to its 1/500 detailed planning, but the province has not reassessed the land price post-adjustment to establish the financial obligations. The inspection agency warned that this delay could result in budget shortfalls. Therefore, Khanh Hoa Provincial People’s Committee has been urged to review the land allocation process and pricing, and recalculate the payable amount before proceeding with further actions.

The Inspectorate’s conclusion recommends that Khanh Hoa Provincial People’s Committee address the issue by recovering the improperly deducted amounts, reassessing financial obligations for each project, and reviewing the responsibilities of involved organizations and individuals. Any detected legal violations should be referred to the competent authorities for further action.

Nha Trang Bay Joint Stock Company was established on November 25, 2010, in Nha Trang, primarily operating in the real estate sector. The former CEO and legal representative, Ms. Cao Thi Thu Hien (born 1977), was succeeded by Mr. Tran Duc Long (born 1980). The company’s charter capital currently stands at approximately 867 billion VND, doubling after the adjustment in late November.

Tu Kinh

– 08:57 02/01/2026

You may also like

Halting Negotiations with Japan on Ninh Thuận 2 Nuclear Power Investment Cooperation

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has directed the Ministry of Industry and Trade to proactively inform Japan of Vietnam’s decision to withdraw from the Ninh Thuan 2 nuclear power project. This move signifies a strategic shift in Vietnam’s energy investment priorities, marking the end of the proposed collaboration on this specific nuclear power initiative.

Deputy Prime Minister: Land Issues Remain a Major Challenge for Inspection Efforts

In 2026, rapid urbanization and accelerated development will demand a more robust inspection sector to prevent violations and resolve project bottlenecks.

2026 Major Project Inspections: Uncovering Potential Construction Violations

In 2026, the Inspection Agency for Complaint and Denunciation Resolution in the Construction Sector (Agency VII) will conduct seven comprehensive inspections across construction, transportation infrastructure, and real estate. These audits will focus on large-scale projects and entities with significant influence and potential risk of violations.

Mandatory Asset Declaration for Officials: Supplemental Reporting Required for Changes Exceeding 1 Billion VND from January 1st to 7th

The amended Law on Anti-Corruption, which revises and supplements several provisions of the existing legislation, will come into effect on July 1, 2026.

Government Inspectorate Proposes Revocation of 305 Land Titles for Mỹ Mỹ Resort Project

The Government Inspectorate has recommended that the People’s Committee of Khanh Hoa Province revoke 305 land use right certificates previously issued to the investor of the My My Resort project, located in Cam Lam Commune, Khanh Hoa Province.